🏆 Case Study

Reagan S.: From Running Out of Time on the ACT to Scoring a 33

26 33
TimelineAbout three months, two tests
CoachWitt
GradeSenior
Book a Free Strategy Call →

Reagan is a senior in Louisiana who wants to be an engineer. His top choices were Missouri S&T and the University of Louisiana at Lafayette, and he was aiming for a 30 or higher on the ACT, both for Louisiana’s state scholarship program, TOPS, and for merit aid at out-of-state schools.

The money mattered to him. Missouri S&T estimates that a year there costs an out-of-state engineering student between $50,864 and $59,134, depending on housing. In his first meeting with us, with his parents on the call, Reagan explained why scholarships were the goal: “I’d like to have the best chance I possibly can to get any scholarship or financial aid I can, because I don’t want these guys to spend any more money on college.”

Half of each section, then guessing

Reagan has ADD, and he takes the ACT with extra time. His first ACT, in February, came before that accommodation was in place. He got through about half of each section, guessed on the rest, and scored a 24.

His June ACT, taken with extra time, came back a 26. Even so, he didn’t finish a single section. The ACT mixes harder questions in among easier ones, and when Reagan hit a hard one, he stayed on it. He told us that on the June test, “all of a sudden, I’d get one that would take me five minutes or more to get through.”

He had been practicing with free questions online, but they didn’t look like the questions on the real test. “I felt like I was answering questions that weren’t going to help me,” he said. He started with us on June 22, right after that June test.

Two tests and a pacing plan

Every student starts with our diagnostic, a full-length practice ACT. Reagan’s showed his coach, Witt, where his time was going and which sections had the most room to grow, and Witt built the plan from it.

Most colleges accept a superscore, which takes a student’s best score in each section from different test dates and averages them into one composite. So Witt split the work across two tests. Reagan spent July’s practice on English and Reading, and saved Math, the section where he ran out of time most, for September.

Witt built pacing into every timed section Reagan practiced. When a question started eating his time, he learned to rule out the answers he could, make an educated guess, and move on. In August he finished a timed practice test with 45 seconds to spare.

Witt also made Reagan’s practice harder than the real test. It’s a strategy we use for certain students, especially ones who run out of time: when practice is harder than test day, the real test feels easier by comparison. For Reagan, that meant practicing on older versions of the ACT, which fit more questions into less time than the current test. About two weeks in, he figured out what Witt was doing: “Oh, wait, I’ve been practicing with a weighted vest.” Looking back, he called it “probably the biggest tool of all.”

After every practice test, Witt had him go back over each question he missed and work out why, so the same mistakes wouldn’t follow him to test day. Once his scores were high, that was the hardest part. “Doing the corrections after you’ve plateaued at a high score is so mind-grueling,” he said later. “It hurts. It’s mentally painful. But I wouldn’t change it.”

A loud room in July

The July test room was noisy and distracting, and Reagan came out of it frustrated. His scores went up anyway. He scored a 28, two points higher than in June. His English, the focus of July’s plan, went up seven points, and his Math went up five.

His dad wrote to Witt after the results came in: “Reagan is really putting in the work.”

Senior year without burning out

Then school started, along with cross country. Over the summer Reagan had been putting in almost five hours a day, between practice tests and going back over every question he missed, and Witt noticed it starting to wear on him.

Witt had him take a couple of days off to reset. Then Witt rebuilt his practice around the school day, with timed sections in his free periods, shorter sessions on weeknights, and full practice tests on weekends.

Reagan wrote to Witt in late August: “This ACT is SUPER important to me, more than I think anyone is aware.”

By then, Reagan’s practice scores were in the 31 to 33 range, so his content and strategy were where they needed to be. Witt could also see the long weeks catching up with him. So for the last few weeks before the test, Witt slowed down his workload and had him focus on fine-tuning, to keep him from burning out before test day. “It was exactly what I needed before that ACT,” Reagan said, “because I wasn’t exhausted by that point.”

Every section, for the first time

Reagan took the September ACT on the 19th. Two days later, Witt asked how it went.

Slack messages: Reagan's coach Witt asks 'Hey @Reagan, How did the test go?' and Reagan replies 'Wonderful! I finished every section!' and 'The math felt really easy'
Witt checking in after the September test, and Reagan's reply. Surnames and Reagan's photo are blurred. Tap or click the image to see it full size.

It was the first time he had finished every section of a real ACT. Scores came out on October 6, and Reagan didn’t want to share his in a message.

Slack message from Reagan: 'I got my score, can we schedule a meeting tomorrow for me to tell you and we can talk about it, or do you need know right now. I wanna tell you in person (by zoom).'
Reagan's message to Witt the day scores came out. His surname and photo are blurred.

The next evening, on Zoom, he told Witt: “I finished every section on the test, which was a first for me. And after long, hard practice, we got a 33 in one sitting.”

He had scored a 33. His Math was a 31, his English a 33, and his Reading a 34. The Math surprised him most, since it was the section where he used to run out of time: “I was not expecting to get a 31 in math. I was thinking if I could get a 30, that would be awesome.”

That’s seven points higher than his June test, on his second test with us. Later in the call, Reagan named the difference himself: “I didn’t even finish any of the sections on the test where I got a 26.”

Looking back in November, Reagan admitted he hadn’t expected a score that high. “In my head, I would have been content with a 30,” he said. “I was really doubtful of my capability to get something as high as a 33.” He worked as hard as he could anyway. “I put in the work, and it worked out.”

Missouri S&T

On November 6, Reagan told Witt he had been accepted to Missouri S&T, his first choice.

Slack messages: Reagan writes 'Also, I just got accepted to Missouri S&T!!! Not accepting their admission yet, still waiting to see if we can get the cost down a bit more, but aside from that I'm really excited!' and Witt replies 'Congratulations!!! Very happy for you. Did you end up applying for that scholarship we talked about?'
Reagan's message about Missouri S&T, and Witt's reply. Surnames and Reagan's photo are blurred. Tap or click the image to see it full size.

By the middle of November, Reagan had heard back from three colleges, and all three said yes: Missouri S&T, the University of Louisiana at Lafayette, and Mississippi State. “Three for three so far,” he told Witt.

His scores changed how he saw his chances. “With Missouri, honestly, I thought, I think I can get in, but I’m not sure,” he said. “But once I saw those jumps, I was like, no, I can definitely do this.”

In early November, Reagan and his dad toured the Missouri S&T campus. His dad had never heard of the school and went in with low expectations, and it blew him away. As Reagan tells it, his dad told him, “I don’t believe this college is a mistake if you end up going here.”

Reagan hasn’t made his final choice yet, because his family is still comparing costs and scholarship offers. Several admissions counselors told him that even though his GPA is just below the cutoff for a Missouri S&T scholarship, he has “a really high, strong ACT.” He plans to apply before the December 1 deadline.

Near the end of the program, Reagan sent Witt a note.

The end of a Slack message from Reagan to Witt: 'Otherwise, We've achieved more than I ever thought possible, and I can't thank you enough for your support! You were a real friend through this process, and though I may never see you again after all of this, I hope in leaving this I can you a friend, so thank you.'
The end of Reagan's note to Witt.

His mom, Laurie, left us a Google review in November.

Five-star Google review from Laurie: 'Our son went from a 26 to a 33 (in one sitting - not just Super Score) within 2 tests. It worked because the plan was clear, there was a coach and accountability, and our son was committed. He worked really hard to apply the coaching and got to own his results - he saw his effort pay off. It has opened college doors and unlocked scholarships he wouldn't have gotten otherwise. Boosted Brain was well worth the investment.'
Laurie's Google review. Her surname and photo are blurred.

On his last call with Witt, Reagan said he hoped he’d “set a good example for any other ADD students who come through this program.” He also had a message for them: “I know your ADD is telling you to just stop and take a break. But if you just keep going, the rewards are unbelievable.”

What we did differently

  • Started with a full-length practice test to see where his time was going, and built his pacing plan from it.
  • Split the work across two tests: English and Reading for July, then Math for September.
  • Practiced pacing on every timed section: make an educated guess on a question that's eating time, and move on.
  • Made his practice harder than the real test, with older, longer versions of the ACT, so test day would feel easier to finish.
  • Rebuilt his practice around school and cross country once his senior year started, then lightened his workload in the last weeks before the test so he'd go in fresh.

Coached by

Witt

Every Boosted Brains coach has a perfect or near-perfect ACT score and has been personally trained by Carson Weekley (perfect 36) and Martin (Head of Student Success).

🎯 Want this kind of result for your student?

Book a Free Strategy Call

We'll review your student's current score, target schools, and timeline — then tell you straight whether sprint coaching is the right fit.

Book a Free Strategy Call →

← Back to all reviews and case studies

🚀 Ready to Get Started?

Your student's best score
is closer than you think

Book a free strategy call with our team. We'll review your student's situation and build a custom gameplan — no commitment required.

Book Your Free Strategy Call →